I am not a big fan of Buzz Hargrove but heâ€™s probably right. Hargrove blames Harper but itâ€™s much more complicated than that.
University of Toronto historian Laurel MacDowell says Canada has shifted from an industrial to a service-based economy.
She says the dominant multi-national service-oriented companies, like Wal-Mart, are known for their anti-union views.
Hargrove says labour activists need to get creative if they want to turn the tide in their favour.
He says the plan to merge the CAW and the Communications, Energy and Paperworkers Union of Canada is a big step in the right direction.
I am going to say that with the U.S. economy in a slow recovery with high unemployment and states desperate for investment that it is a big hammer over any negotiations because if labour doesnâ€™t make the concessions you want, itâ€™s easy to move to Indiana, Michigan, or Ohio and find a motivated, educated and trained workforce that is largely unemployed. Why pay high wages in Saskatchewan or Ontario when you can get the same product made for less money somewhere else.
Itâ€™s not fair to those that get squeezed in it but welcome to the foreseeable future.
As most of you know, the Canadian Auto Workers union were negotiating to save the jobs at the Caterpillar plant in London, Ontario. Negotiations went so well that Caterpillar shut down the plant and moved the production to Indiana where workers were willing for work for 50% less. Say whatever you want to say about how cruel Caterpillar is, $16.00/hour is a lot better than nothing and that is what those workers are left with in London. 700 jobs lost, a contentious severance package and Caterpillar becomes even more profitable.
Believe it or not, the problem isnâ€™t Caterpillar. Are they evil? Yes. Are profit hungry? Yes. The problem was that only a couple hundred miles away were educated and trained American workers willing to work for half of what workers in London, Ontario are willing to work for and the CAW ignored that fact. Both Obama and Romney are trying to revitalize the American manufacturing sector and this is how it is going to happen. With a decline in demand in many sectors, it means that Ontario is going to be pitted against Indiana and Saskatchewan against Wisconsin. The manufacturing jobs in China arenâ€™t coming back for a very long time if ever and we are going to have to get used to the realities that it is going to come down to jurisdiction against jurisdiction and union local against union local. Those that wonâ€™t make concessions or offer subsidies will lose jobs and even if you do, once the subsidies stop, the jobs will move to whoever will give them.
While $16/hour looked repulsive to the local union in London, it looked like a good paying job in Indiana and I have a feeling that is a story we will hear again and again until unions like the CAW understand that no matter how intense their strike, a 50% in wages will attract a lot of companies. Itâ€™s the new normal and it is going to happen again and again.