â€œYou came, you shopped, you dressed nice â€“ you went to the mall. Thatâ€™s what people did,â€ says Lawless, a pseudonymous photographer who grew up in a suburb of nearby Cleveland. â€œIt was very consumer-driven and kind of had an ugly side, but there was something beautiful about it. There was something there.â€
Gazing down at the motionless escalators, dead plants and empty benches below, he adds: â€œItâ€™s still beautiful, though. Itâ€™s almost like ancient ruins.â€
Dying shopping malls are speckled across the United States, often in middle-class suburbs wrestling with socioeconomic shifts. Some, like Rolling Acres, have already succumbed. Estimates on the share that might close or be repurposed in coming decades range from 15 to 50%. Americans are returning downtown; online shopping is taking a 6% bite out of brick-and-mortar sales; and to many iPhone-clutching, city-dwelling and frequently jobless young people, the culture that spawned satire like Mallrats seems increasingly dated, even cartoonish.
According to longtime retail consultant Howard Davidowitz, numerous midmarket malls, many of them born during the countryâ€™s suburban explosion after the second world war, could very well share Rolling Acresâ€™ fate. â€œTheyâ€™re going, going, gone,â€ Davidowitz says. â€œTheyâ€™re trying to change; theyâ€™re trying to get different kinds of anchors, discount stores â€¦ [But] whatâ€™s going on is the customers donâ€™t have the fucking money. Thatâ€™s it. This isnâ€™t rocket science.â€
Of course it didnâ€™t help that they were built with no urban planning principles in mind.
For mid-century Americans, these gleaming marketplaces provided an almost utopian alternative to the urban commercial district, an artificial downtown with less crime and fewer vermin. As Joan Didion wrote in 1979, malls became â€œcities in which no one lives but everyone consumesâ€. Peppered throughout disconnected suburbs, they were a place to see and be seen, something shoppers have craved since the days of the Greek agora. And they quickly matured into a self-contained ecosystem, with their own species â€“ mall rats, mall cops, mall walkers â€“ and an annual feeding frenzy known as Black Friday.
â€œLocal governments had never dealt with this sort of development and were basically bamboozled [by developers],â€ Underhill says of the mall planning process. â€œIn contrast to Europe, where shopping malls are much more a product of public-private negotiation and funding, here in the US most were built under what I call â€˜cowboy conditionsâ€™.â€
Shopping centres in Europe might contain grocery stores or childcare centres, while those in Japan are often built around mass transit. But the suburban American variety is hard to get to and sells â€œapparel and gifts and damn little elseâ€, Underhill says.
Same thing in the largely empty Confederation Mall. Â The mall emptied out after rents skyrocketed in Saskatoon. Â What used to be disposable income is now needed for rent. Â In that way, malls are a reflection of the economic health of the surrounding communities.