Over the last couple of weeks I have seen three minor accidents along the northbound lane on Idylwyld South. All three have been minor and have “exchanged paint” to use the old NASCAR phrase. They have been caused by someone trying to brake or avoid a massive pothole around a manhole cover which had been created but not repaired by a City of Saskatoon crew.
Today while caught in traffic along there, Wendy and I watched a man who was going no faster than 20 kph hit the pothole, blow his tire and bend his rim on a pothole that had been there for weeks.
Whenever I talk to any of you about potholes, I get told, “report it on the website”. When a pothole in on one of the major thoroughfares in this city, driven by police, fire, city crews and even you as councillors, one should not have to report a pothole to the city, it should be fixed like it would be in any other city in Canada. Especially when the pothole was created as part of a sewer upgrade*.
I have heard many stories this summer of Saskatoonians travelling to other cities and hearing apologies for the state of their roads while those same people are going, “this is so much better than the roads we have have in Saskatoon”. Some of the ways people have described our roads are “war torn”, “goat trails,” and most of all “unsafe”.
They are unsafe to our tires, our rims, and our suspensions. They are also unsafe for cyclists and pedestrians. It’s embarrassing that you as a group has allowed our streets to get to this point.
It’s not like you don’t know this would happen. The 2012 Roads Reports and reports before that ask for more money and tell you each year that unless we have more money, this is going to happen. You kept telling people how you heard about their concerns regarding roads on the doorsteps. Instead you gave a small increase and congratulated yourselves on the back despite knowing it wasn’t enough. Road repair costs rise about 15% each year but Council decides to give about .5% of an increase each year leading to a very big and unsafe gap in services. You hope to have enough money budgeted to bring hold the status quo by 2020. By that time there may not be any roads left and the yearly amount needed to fix our roads will be much, much higher.
Maybe city crews can’t find the potholes because street cleaning in this city takes months. On Friday I was in City Park and they were finally cleaning it. It was July 12! Two months citizens of City Park have had to deal with gravel strewn and dirty streets because again, the City of Saskatoon won’t pay for the equipment needed to clean our streets. We have such a short summer, you would think this would be a priority but it isn’t. An email from another ward councillor today showed that much of that ward hadn’t been cleaned yet so don’t feel back City Park. The quality of street sweeping is poor to say the least. Talking to councillors in others wards I hear the same thing. Locally I heard the sweepers but to be honest, our roads are marginally cleaner.
Sure we have the lowest taxes of any city our size in Canada but at the end of the day there is a reason for that, no city can maintain it’s infrastructure at the current rate of funding. We may as well have Prosperity Saskatoon but we have roads that failing and a bridge that is a laughing stock of the country. Instead of fixing what we have, all you can talk about is how we need to build more stuff (that needs to be maintained) so we can grow to a city of 1 million people.
While we are talking about growing to a city of a million people; here is a little bit of information you might find useful, cities can’t grow themselves. It’s the national and provincial economies that decide that. It took Calgary 45 years to grow from 250,000 to a million people yet for some reason, we need to start building today. Hence the $30 million extra for addition lanes on the north commuter bridge that your own city administration recommended against. Then again, who am I to question policy made out of a campaign promise?
Our provincial economy is far different than Alberta’s oil based economy. The amount of head office oversight that a potash mine takes compared to thousands of oil wells all over the province is miniscule. We may be overjoyed by BHP Billiton moving it’s Canadian head office to Saskatoon but look at the result, a couple of stories of downtown office space. It’s not a reflection of Saskatoon, it’s a reflection of the economy of the province we live in.
Combine that with a city council that just can’t get that quality of life matter in a city and you have a place where companies won’t be able to attract talent to and if they can, they won’t be able to keep it. Most of the cities that are growing in Canada have higher taxes because a) growth costs b) you need to have great public amenities to have a city that top talent wants to live in.
Eventually we are going to have to make a decision as a city. If we keep on this path with crumbling roads and infrastructure many will just choose to leave. For those that are left, we are going to have to borrow heavily to pay for the stuff that should have been paid for al along just like Toronto has had to do. You can’t run old buses, garbage trucks, and city vehicles forever. Eventually something is going to have to give and then you have to start paying for bills of broken equipment, water pipes, and roads. When those bills come due, it’s over whelming.
Council needs to stop playing politics and start doing their fiduciary responsibility for the citizens of Saskatoon and start taking proper care of our infrastructure and city. If they don’t, the only good news is that they won’t need to spend so much time worrying about it because we will find another group of public servants that will.
* I shouldn’t be that surprised by a city crew not repairing a pothole. I had to personally intervene several years ago while a city run backhoe hit a car and was about to drive off. The utility cut took a couple of years to get fixed. I also listened to Saskatoon Light & Power crews lie about a pole failure while I was working downtown where they went home for the weekend and left a power pole in a hole without any supports. The weather warmed up and it fell over. We aren’t hiring the best and the brightest.