Bill has a wonderful post on writing. The entire thing is worth reading but this one got me thinking
In 2004, Nielsen BookScan tracked the sales of 1.2 million books and found that nine hundred and fifty thousand of them sold fewer than ninety-nine copies.
So we are looking at author royalties of a couple hundred bucks and a couple of conference speaking gigs. In the end is it worth the effort?
Bill’s prescription to the cure is to write better stories and he is dead on correct (although writing stories is harder than it sounds, check out this editorial review from Amazon.com) . Like a lot of bloggers, I get a lot of books sent to me by almost every major publishing house. In fact two came today and both of them look horrible. In fact 99% of the books that I see coming my way, including many by friends are horrible. They are poorly researched, not fact checked (if you are going to use history or science as an illustration, do your homework people!) It’s one of the reasons why I no longer talk about theological titles here, so many of them aren’t worth my time to read and when I do read them, I am confronted by the fact that these are three hours I will never get back. Do I keep wasting time on this or move on? I generally find something by Michael Lewis or Steven Johnson and move on (which proves Bill’s point).
My suggestion for a lot of writers is not to bother writing a book period. Forget the conferences, forget the interviews on Christian radio, forget the church basement book signings. Instead throw your efforts into whatever it is that you are good at. Chances are your ideas are intrinsically linked to your personality and your context and not as transferable as you would think. That’s why even if I lost some weight and got a blond wig and a sailboat, I still couldn’t lead like Bill Hybels. The reason isn’t that I didn’t mention his golf shirts (and let’s be honest, he has some nice golf shirts), it is that I am not Bill Hybels and I live in Saskatoon, not South Barrington.
Secondly, is the time away from doing what you do well or time away from learning something that you don’t do well, worth 1000 book sales and $5,000 in royalties? Is the mini-book tour worth it? Is the time spamming your friends worth it? What about moderating message boards on infrequentbooksales.com, and trying to get people to fan you on Facebook worth it?
Thirdly, is giving the copyright of you idea to your publisher worth it? Especially in the church I don’t know why we don’t see more writers open sourcing their content. If you believe your idea came from the Holy Spirit, does turning that over to FOX (though Zondervan) seem to be the best course of action? If you want to publish at least consider negotiating so your book is published under a Creative Commons license.
I have heard Michael Slaughter of Ginghamsburg talk about writing being the best way to influence people and in some ways he is right but as Bill Kinnon pointed out, is less then 100 copies influencing anyone other than your closest friends?
Would the time be better of spent writing a blog (and then doing what Guy Kawasaki did and put it out as a book), doing an excellent series of videos on YouTube which tell your story (great example of this here or here – what either of these stories be as compelling in book form?), or what about creating a world class webcast like what Spencer Burke did with TheOoze.tv or an excellent podcast? If you are committed to writing, why not introduce your ideas to communities like TheOoze or Next-Wave?
I like Rob Bell’s writing but if I was him and had to choose between writing and Nooma, I would choose Nooma. Also wouldn’t the time be better spent putting it into whatever made you think you should write about it. I am not being flippant. I remember the great line in Jim Collins’ book Built to Last where he talks about Lee Iacocca being distracted from running Chrysler because he was too busy being Lee Iacocca.
Finally, I know the church goes on and on about visionary leadership and visionary pastors and everyone including the pastors dog is a visionary (Maggi is visioning a piece of pizza as I type) but there have few game changing ideas that I have read in the last decade. Most of it is regurgitated stuff and doesn’t need to see the light of day again. Maybe the best use of our time would be coming up with some new ideas, instead of repackaging some old ones.